QAS FAQ - Revision history

Sifaan at 10:32, 5 December 2025

2025-12-05T10:32:24Z

Sifaan at 07:36, 3 December 2025

2025-12-03T07:36:18Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:36, 3 December 2025
Line 16:		Line 16:
	== How much does it cost to participate in the QAS? ==		== How much does it cost to participate in the QAS? ==
	Nothing. We want the QAS to be accessible for everyone, so we will never charge any fees.		Nothing. We want the QAS to be accessible for everyone, so we will never charge any fees.

	~~== Who can Participate in the RCE QAS ==~~
	~~Please see [https://rights-centric.education/rce-qas-participants RCE QAS Participants]~~

	~~== I am not eligible to be a Participant, how can I help? ==~~
	~~Please see [https://rights-centric.education/qas-advisors RCE QAS Advisors]~~

	== What do I do as a Participant? ==		== What do I do as a Participant? ==

Sifaan: Created page with "== Who is the "civil society" implementing this, and why? == # The Rights-Centric Education Network is a movement of individuals and organizations who believe that presently mainstreamed educational practices are not compatible with Child Rights (which is not surprising when we recognise that those educational practices predate the modern Human Rights discourse by centuries) # Many members of the RCE Network are involved in educational environments where educational pra..."

2025-11-26T07:11:04Z

Created page with "== Who is the "civil society" implementing this, and why? == # The Rights-Centric Education Network is a movement of individuals and organizations who believe that presently mainstreamed educational practices are not compatible with Child Rights (which is not surprising when we recognise that those educational practices predate the modern Human Rights discourse by centuries) # Many members of the RCE Network are involved in educational environments where educational pra..."

New page

== Who is the "civil society" implementing this, and why? ==
# The Rights-Centric Education Network is a movement of individuals and organizations who believe that presently mainstreamed educational practices are not compatible with Child Rights (which is not surprising when we recognise that those educational practices predate the modern Human Rights discourse by centuries)
# Many members of the RCE Network are involved in educational environments where educational practices are more aligned with Human Rights (and especially Child Rights), and recognized the Quality Assurance System proposed by the UN as a powerful opportunity to bring democratic, rights-centric educational practices to the mainstream.

== I want to know more about the "Why" ==
# Watch the recording of the inauguration [https://youtu.be/gQDbwCNIeVE here]
# If you would like more details, watch the keynote by Sifaan Zavahir (a Founding Member of the RCE Network) at the International Democratic Education Conference 2025 held in Belgium on August 1-7. This presentation was mainly addressing the reasons why schools and families identifying as Democratic should be early adopters of the Quality Assurance System. See [https://www.eudec2025.org/mainstreaming-democratic-education/ Description] and [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnxknVKxOtw Recording].
# Watch the recording of a call hosted by Je'anna Clements (also a Founding Member) on the benefits of being an early adopter of the QAS [https://youtu.be/qux_1_cv14M here].

== Why should I participate in the RCE QAS? ==
# It affirms your commitment to the Rights of the Children in your educational environment.
# It gives confidence to the children in your care that you will do your best to respect and fulfill their Rights.
# It recognizes and showcases the good work that you do.
# It can help overcome opposition, and gain acceptance, from people who do not understand how what you do advances Children's Rights.

== How much does it cost to participate in the QAS? ==
Nothing. We want the QAS to be accessible for everyone, so we will never charge any fees.

== Who can Participate in the RCE QAS ==
Please see [https://rights-centric.education/rce-qas-participants RCE QAS Participants]

== I am not eligible to be a Participant, how can I help? ==
Please see [https://rights-centric.education/qas-advisors RCE QAS Advisors]

== What do I do as a Participant? ==
# To the fullest extent possible, explain to the children you are working with why you are doing this (broadly, that they have human rights, and you want to ensure that their education respects and fulfils those rights as much as possible). A big part of realising children's rights is respecting their right to participate in decisions that affect them, and it is good to start that process by involving them in the decision to participate in the RCE QAS
# "Sign" the [https://rights-centric.education/pledge Pledge to join RCE Quality Assurance System] If you haven't already done so, the form will also allow you to
## Join the RCE Network; The QAS is offered by the RCE to its members, so membership is required - but don't worry, it's free :)
## Sign the [https://www.rights-centric.education/declaration Declaration of Child Rights-Centric Education]; The QAS exists to support the changes called for in the Declaration; so being a signatory is required.
# Make your first Report, which will outline what is the current situation in your environment in terms of child rights, and what have you done (or intend to do), to make things better.
# Submit further reports as and when possible (e.g. progress reports, or to describe a practice that you didn't have time to do before, or to update on a new initiative, etc.)
# When submitting reports, you are
## expected to implement certain practices called for in the First World Program for Human Rights Education, as and when possible
## encouraged to make use of the content of reports submitted by other Participants (that is how we share and make use of good practices from diverse contexts and countries)

== This reporting sounds like a lot of work / I'm worried I won't get it right ==
This is a participatory framework. There is no "right" or "wrong" way - rather, we will all help each other to be better. Let's start where we can, to the extent that we can, and just keep improving from there.

== How will this QAS actually "Assure Quality"? ==
Just like citizens in a democratic country will compare their experiences against their expectations (which will be informed by what they see happening in other countries) and engage in participatory practices (e.g. civil society action) to advance their rights, we envisage that children in educational settings participating in the QAS will compare their experiences with what is happening in other settings, and engage in participatory practices (e.g. dialogue with school leaders) to advance their rights.

== Is there any precedent for this? ==
We are drawing inspiration from several areas
# The reporting process that is part of every Human Rights treaty - if a country ratifies a treaty, they commit to report on their progress. (ChatGPT explanation for CRC [https://chatgpt.com/share/6854eed7-abcc-8013-9a4f-d53f6ea8e2a8 here]). Likewise, we expect that if a "school" (or other educational environment) signs up to be part of the QAS (because it gives them recognition for caring about Child Rights in Education and access to peer support) they will also make periodic reports on their progress.
## RCE QAS reports will be likewise public (see CRC related submissions in the UN repository [https://tbinternet.ohchr.org/_layouts/15/treatybodyexternal/TBSearch.aspx?Lang=en&TreatyID=5 here])
## Unlike the UN reporting process, there will NOT be a formal review process, because there is no authority that can conduct it. Instead, the accountability will be to the Rights-holders, i.e. the Children. These reports should be included in the democratic decision making processes in the school itself, and will empower children to hold adults accountable to their commitments
# The Forest School Association is an example of a network of schools coming together to organize their own [https://forestschoolassociation.org/forest-school-qualification/ Qualification System]
## Their path was to create a system where there is an authority above the schools that determines how well each school is performing.
## For the RCE QAS, we expect that it is the children in the school (or other environment) who should determine how well their school is performing in terms of respecting their rights (much like citizens decide how happy they are with their governments and express themselves through franchise)
## There can, of course, be independent accreditation / certification bodies that analyse / certify the reports (e.g. and show that school X has met 60% of their commitments while school Y has only met 40%) and provide supporting evidence (just like citizens in a democracy access information from a variety of sources)
# UNICEF's Rights-Respecting Schools Award (RRSA) is very similar in terms of goals, and their [https://www.unicef.org.uk/rights-respecting-schools/how-we-create-change-for-children/theory-of-change/ Theory of Change] is useful (Thank you Don Berg for sharing this). Comparing QAS to RRSA:
## We too will have [https://www.unicef.org.uk/rights-respecting-schools/resources/teaching-resources/best-practice-case-studies/ Case Studies]
## Unlike the RRSA, we will not start by accepting the presently mainstreamed system of schools as the baseline - that system was designed to violate, not advance, human rights and no amount of icing on top can fix it.
## Like in the comparison with Forest School, there will not be an authority that will set benchmarks (RRSA has Bronze, Silver, Gold levels)
## There will not be any participating fees.
## Derry Hannam shared [https://www.progressiveeducation.org/research-into-childrens-rights-education/ this article] he wrote for EUDEC about RRSA back in 2011. This gives more information on the background of the award and its impact.

== Suggested Additional Reading ==
# Children's rights group KRÄTZÄ published a "Human rights report", called "The Discrimination of The Child". It compared the real life (reality) of children in Germany with the provisions given by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR). 16 of the 30 paragraphs weren't valid or adults/government didn't abide to them. The report was handed over to the President of Germany on the 50th Anniversary of the UDHR (1998). Among other things, it identifies the school system as the core area where human rights are being violated. Website (in German) [http://kraetzae.de/menschenrechtsreport/ here] and [https://en.kraetzae.de/hrreport/ here] (Thank you Mike Weimann for sharing this)
# KRÄTZÄ also wrote to the UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Education when he visited Germany in 2006 (letter, in German, [https://kraetzae.de/schule/munoz/ here]) (Thanks again, Mike) - if it is possible to engage the SR in the QAS it would be great; in the past the SR's have grudgingly accepted home-schooling as an option to realise the Right to Education but are deeply skeptical about non-state Education. The QAS may help alleviate these fears

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:32, 5 December 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	== Who is the "civil society" implementing this, and why? ==		== Who is the "civil society" implementing this, and why? ==
	# The Rights-Centric Education Network is a movement of individuals and organizations who believe that presently mainstreamed educational practices are not compatible with Child Rights (which is not surprising when we recognise that those educational practices predate the modern Human Rights discourse by centuries)		# The Rights-Centric Education Network is a movement of individuals and organizations who believe that presently mainstreamed educational practices are not compatible with Child Rights (which is not surprising when we recognise that those educational practices predate the modern Human Rights discourse by centuries).
	# Many members of the RCE Network are involved in educational environments where educational practices are more aligned with Human Rights (and especially Child Rights), and ~~recognized~~ the Quality Assurance System proposed by the UN as a powerful opportunity to bring democratic, rights-centric educational practices to the mainstream.		# Many members of the RCE Network are involved in educational environments where educational practices are more aligned with Human Rights (and especially Child Rights), and recognize the Quality Assurance System proposed by the UN as a powerful opportunity to bring democratic, rights-centric educational practices to the mainstream.

	== I want to know more about the "Why" ==		== I want to know more about the "Why" ==
	# Watch the recording of the inauguration [https://youtu.be/gQDbwCNIeVE here]		# Watch the recording of the inauguration [https://youtu.be/gQDbwCNIeVE here].
	# If you would like more details, watch the keynote by Sifaan Zavahir (a Founding Member of the RCE Network) at the International Democratic Education Conference 2025 held in Belgium on August 1-7. This presentation was mainly addressing the reasons why schools and families identifying as Democratic should be early adopters of the Quality Assurance System. See [https://www.eudec2025.org/mainstreaming-democratic-education/ Description] and [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnxknVKxOtw Recording].		# If you would like more details, watch the keynote by Sifaan Zavahir (a Founding Member of the RCE Network) at the International Democratic Education Conference 2025 held in Belgium on August 1-7. This presentation was mainly addressing the reasons why schools and families identifying as Democratic should be early adopters of the Quality Assurance System. See [https://www.eudec2025.org/mainstreaming-democratic-education/ Description] and [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LnxknVKxOtw Recording].
	# Watch the recording of a call hosted by Je'anna Clements (also a Founding Member) on the benefits of being an early adopter of the QAS [https://youtu.be/qux_1_cv14M here].		# Watch the recording of a call hosted by Je'anna Clements (also a Founding Member) on the benefits of being an early adopter of the QAS [https://youtu.be/qux_1_cv14M here].
Line 12:		Line 12:
	# It gives confidence to the children in your care that you will do your best to respect and fulfill their Rights.		# It gives confidence to the children in your care that you will do your best to respect and fulfill their Rights.
	# It recognizes and showcases the good work that you do.		# It recognizes and showcases the good work that you do.
	# It can help overcome opposition, and gain acceptance, from people who do not understand how what you do advances Children's Rights.		# It can help overcome opposition and gain acceptance from people who do not understand how what you do advances Children's Rights.

	== How much does it cost to participate in the QAS? ==		== How much does it cost to participate in the QAS? ==
Line 19:		Line 19:
	== What do I do as a Participant? ==		== What do I do as a Participant? ==
	# To the fullest extent possible, explain to the children you are working with why you are doing this (broadly, that they have human rights, and you want to ensure that their education respects and fulfils those rights as much as possible). A big part of realising children's rights is respecting their right to participate in decisions that affect them, and it is good to start that process by involving them in the decision to participate in the RCE QAS		# To the fullest extent possible, explain to the children you are working with why you are doing this (broadly, that they have human rights, and you want to ensure that their education respects and fulfils those rights as much as possible). A big part of realising children's rights is respecting their right to participate in decisions that affect them, and it is good to start that process by involving them in the decision to participate in the RCE QAS
	# "Sign" the [https://rights-centric.education/pledge Pledge to join RCE Quality Assurance System] If you haven't already done so, the form will also allow you to		# "Sign" the [https://rights-centric.education/pledge Pledge to join RCE Quality Assurance System]. If you haven't already done so, the form will also allow you to
	## Join the RCE Network; The QAS is offered by the RCE to its members, so membership is required - but don't worry, it's free :)		## Join the RCE Network; The QAS is offered by the RCE to its members, so membership is required - but don't worry, it's free :)
	## Sign the [https://www.rights-centric.education/declaration Declaration of Child Rights-Centric Education]; The QAS exists to support the changes called for in the Declaration; so being a signatory is required.		## Sign the [https://www.rights-centric.education/declaration Declaration of Child Rights-Centric Education]; The QAS exists to support the changes called for in the Declaration, so being a signatory is required.
	# Make your first Report, which will outline what is the current situation in your environment in terms of child rights, and what have ~~you~~ done (or intend to do), to make things better.		# Make your first Report, which will outline what is the current situation in your environment in terms of child rights, and what you have done (or intend to do), to make things better.
	# Submit further reports as and when possible (e.g. progress reports, or to describe a practice that you didn't have time to do before, or to update on a new initiative, etc.)		# Submit further reports as and when possible (e.g. progress reports, or to describe a practice that you didn't have time to do before, or to update on a new initiative, etc.).
	# When submitting reports, you are		# When submitting reports, you are
	## expected to implement certain practices called for in the First World Program for Human Rights Education, as and when possible		## expected to implement certain practices called for in the First World Program for Human Rights Education, as and when possible.
	## encouraged to make use of the content of reports submitted by other Participants (that is how we share and make use of good practices from diverse contexts and countries)		## encouraged to make use of the content of reports submitted by other Participants (that is how we share and make use of good practices from diverse contexts and countries).

	== This reporting sounds like a lot of work / I'm worried I won't get it right ==		== This reporting sounds like a lot of work / I'm worried I won't get it right ==
Line 36:		Line 36:
	== Is there any precedent for this? ==		== Is there any precedent for this? ==
	We are drawing inspiration from several areas		We are drawing inspiration from several areas
	# The reporting process that is part of every Human Rights treaty - if a country ratifies a treaty, they commit to report on their progress. (ChatGPT explanation for CRC [https://chatgpt.com/share/6854eed7-abcc-8013-9a4f-d53f6ea8e2a8 here]). Likewise, we expect that if a "school" (or other educational environment) signs up to be part of the QAS (because it gives them recognition for caring about Child Rights in Education and access to peer support) they will also make periodic reports on their progress.		# The reporting process that is part of every Human Rights treaty - if a country ratifies a treaty, they commit to report on their progress. (ChatGPT explanation for CRC [https://chatgpt.com/share/6854eed7-abcc-8013-9a4f-d53f6ea8e2a8 here]). Likewise, we expect that if a "school" (or other educational environment) signs up to be part of the QAS (because it gives them recognition for caring about Child Rights in Education and access to peer support), they will also make periodic reports on their progress.
	## RCE QAS reports will be ~~likewise~~ public (see CRC related submissions in the UN repository [https://tbinternet.ohchr.org/_layouts/15/treatybodyexternal/TBSearch.aspx?Lang=en&TreatyID=5 here])		## RCE QAS reports will likewise be public (see CRC-related submissions in the UN repository [https://tbinternet.ohchr.org/_layouts/15/treatybodyexternal/TBSearch.aspx?Lang=en&TreatyID=5 here]).
	## Unlike the UN reporting process, there will NOT be a formal review process, because there is no authority that can conduct it. Instead, the accountability will be to the Rights-holders, i.e. the Children. These reports should be included in the democratic decision making processes in the school itself, and will empower children to hold adults accountable to their commitments		## Unlike the UN reporting process, there will NOT be a formal review process, because there is no authority that can conduct it. Instead, the accountability will be to the Rights-holders, i.e. the Children. These reports should be included in the democratic decision-making processes in the school itself, and will empower children to hold adults accountable to their commitments.
	# The Forest School Association is an example of a network of schools coming together to organize their own [https://forestschoolassociation.org/forest-school-qualification/ Qualification System]		# The Forest School Association is an example of a network of schools coming together to organize their own [https://forestschoolassociation.org/forest-school-qualification/ Qualification System].
	## Their path was to create a system where there is an authority above the schools that determines how well each school is performing.		## Their path was to create a system where there is an authority above the schools that determines how well each school is performing.
	## For the RCE QAS, we expect that it is the children in the school (or other environment) who should determine how well their school is performing in terms of respecting their rights (much like citizens decide how happy they are with their governments and express themselves through franchise)		## For the RCE QAS, we expect that it is the children in the school (or other environment) who should determine how well their school is performing in terms of respecting their rights (much like citizens decide how happy they are with their governments and express themselves through franchise).
	## There can, of course, be independent accreditation / certification bodies that analyse / certify the reports (e.g. and show that school X has met 60% of their commitments while school Y has only met 40%) and provide supporting evidence (just like citizens in a democracy access information from a variety of sources)		## There can, of course, be independent accreditation/certification bodies that analyse/certify the reports (e.g. and show that school X has met 60% of their commitments while school Y has only met 40%) and provide supporting evidence (just like citizens in a democracy access information from a variety of sources).
	# UNICEF's Rights-Respecting Schools Award (RRSA) is very similar in terms of goals, and their [https://www.unicef.org.uk/rights-respecting-schools/how-we-create-change-for-children/theory-of-change/ Theory of Change] is useful (Thank you Don Berg for sharing this). Comparing QAS to RRSA:		# UNICEF's Rights-Respecting Schools Award (RRSA) is very similar in terms of goals, and their [https://www.unicef.org.uk/rights-respecting-schools/how-we-create-change-for-children/theory-of-change/ Theory of Change] is useful (Thank you, Don Berg, for sharing this). Comparing QAS to RRSA:
	## We too will have [https://www.unicef.org.uk/rights-respecting-schools/resources/teaching-resources/best-practice-case-studies/ Case Studies]		## We too will have [https://www.unicef.org.uk/rights-respecting-schools/resources/teaching-resources/best-practice-case-studies/ Case Studies].
	## Unlike the RRSA, we will not start by accepting the presently mainstreamed system of schools as the baseline - that system was designed to violate, not advance, human rights and no amount of icing on top can fix it.		## Unlike the RRSA, we will not start by accepting the presently mainstreamed system of schools as the baseline - that system was designed to violate, not advance, human rights and no amount of icing on top can fix it.
	## Like in the comparison with Forest School, there will not be an authority that will set benchmarks (RRSA has Bronze, Silver, Gold levels)		## Like in the comparison with Forest School, there will not be an authority that will set benchmarks (RRSA has Bronze, Silver, Gold levels).
	## There will not be any ~~participating~~ fees.		## There will not be any participation fees.
	## Derry Hannam shared [https://www.progressiveeducation.org/research-into-childrens-rights-education/ this article] he wrote for EUDEC about RRSA back in 2011. This gives more information on the background of the award and its impact.		## Derry Hannam shared [https://www.progressiveeducation.org/research-into-childrens-rights-education/ this article] he wrote for EUDEC about RRSA back in 2011. This gives more information on the background of the award and its impact.

	== Suggested Additional Reading ==		== Suggested Additional Reading ==
	# Children's rights group KRÄTZÄ published a "Human rights report", called "The Discrimination of The Child". It compared the real life (reality) of children in Germany with the provisions given by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR). 16 of the 30 paragraphs weren't valid or adults/government didn't abide to them. The report was handed over to the President of Germany on the 50th Anniversary of the UDHR (1998). Among other things, it identifies the school system as the core area where human rights are being violated. Website (in German) [http://kraetzae.de/menschenrechtsreport/ here] and [https://en.kraetzae.de/hrreport/ here] (Thank you Mike Weimann for sharing this)		# Children's rights group KRÄTZÄ published a "Human rights report", called "The Discrimination of The Child". It compared the real life (reality) of children in Germany with the provisions given by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR). 16 of the 30 paragraphs weren't valid, or adults/government didn't abide by them. The report was handed over to the President of Germany on the 50th Anniversary of the UDHR (1998). Among other things, it identifies the school system as the core area where human rights are being violated. Website (in German) [http://kraetzae.de/menschenrechtsreport/ here] and [https://en.kraetzae.de/hrreport/ here] (Thank you, Mike Weimann, for sharing this).
	# KRÄTZÄ also wrote to the UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Education when he visited Germany in 2006 (letter, in German, [https://kraetzae.de/schule/munoz/ here]) (Thanks again, Mike) - if it is possible to engage the SR in the QAS it would be great; in the past the SR's have grudgingly accepted home-schooling as an option to realise the Right to Education but are deeply skeptical about non-state Education. The QAS may help alleviate these fears		# KRÄTZÄ also wrote to the UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Education when he visited Germany in 2006 (letter, in German, [https://kraetzae.de/schule/munoz/ here]) (Thanks again, Mike) - if it is possible to engage the SR in the QAS it would be great; in the past the SR's have grudgingly accepted home-schooling as an option to realise the Right to Education but are deeply skeptical about non-state Education. The QAS may help alleviate these fears.